Tuesday, November 17, 2009

From No One Is Illegal

Stop Detentions! Stop Deportations! Status for All!
-- a statement on the detained Tamil Refugees and the Canadian Refugee system --

by No One Is Illegal-Toronto and Tamil Youth Organization

Seventy six people from military occupied north and east Sri Lanka
arrived off the coast of BC in a ship on Friday, 16 October, claiming
refugee status. All but one of the men, ethnically Tamil, are still
imprisoned. Days after their arrival, Kenney cut Canada's refugee
acceptance targets by 60%, limiting acceptance to no more than 9,000 -
12,000 people a year. In 2008, the quota was 22,000-29,000 a year.
Without any consultation, the Immigration Minister has undemocratically and fundamentally changed Canada's refugee system. The Immigration Minister has tried to belittle these migrants and their journey as justification for further changes.

These are not the first people to arrive by boat, seeking refuge. Yet
like many before them they find themselves barred from entering
Canada, locked in detention, and awaiting possible deportation.

In 1999, three ships arrived in Canada with 600 people from the Fujian
province in China. They were detained for nearly a year and in the end
only 15 were granted status. The rest were deported. On their return
they were forced in to labor camps.

In 1939, 900 Jewish passengers fleeing Europe on board the MS St.
Louis tried to seek refuge in Canada and were not allowed to disembark. Most were deported to Europe where they died under Nazi blitzkrieg. More than one-third of them were murdered in the Nazi gas chambers and internment camps.

In 1914, 354 people left from British occupied India on board the
Komagata Maru. Moored off the coast of BC with next to no supplies for
four months, essentially in captivity, the ship was forced to return.
Many died en route and more when they arrived in India by British

In every one of these cases, racist xenophobia exploded across Canada.
In 1914, the headlines read, 'Hindus hold meeting and preach sedition
and treason'; in 1939, the Director of Immigration said, 'none is too
many'; in 1999, a Victoria newspaper headline read, 'Go home'; and in
2009, CIC Minister Kenney insists that they are coming in through the 'back door' in a 'generous' system.

But if this is the back door, where is the front door? According to
the Canadian Council for Refugees, the United Nations set a goal of
560,000 resettled refugees for 2008/9 - of these Canada will only
accept about 11,000. This is nearly half of Canada's annual acceptance
rate of 21,400 in the 1980s. Contrast this with Syria, Lebanon and
Jordan who between them accepted 885,000 Iraqi refugees in 2007,
according to UNHCR spokesman Peter Kessler.

Overseas claims can only be made at UNHCR offices, usually in camps,
which Sri Lanka has refused to be established in Tamil Eelam. Over
300,000 internally displaced Tamils have been held by the Sri Lankan
Army for the past two months in barbed-wire fenced internment camps,
where they are subject to massive overcrowding, shortage of food and
medical facilities, abductions, including the abduction of children,
rape, torture, disease, and when the monsoons set in, flooding.

The Times newspaper in England, one of the only journalist sources
that gained entry to the camps, has reported that 1400 civilians are
dying in the camps every single week. People in camps have few ways to
apply for refuge in Canada as there are no nearby UNHCR offices and
access to the Canadian consulate is restricted. Under present Canadian refugee policies, claimants are unlikely to gain status from outside Canada. Migrants have little choice but to arrive at the border with fake
documents and ask for refuge. Exactly the process followed by the
people that arrived last month.

Canada has called the War in Sri Lanka that led to the detention of
over a quarter million people in camps, a "domestic" matter and
demanded "non interference" from the UN. This, while, even Hillary
Clinton has demanded that the Sri Lankan army be charged with War
Crimes for using rape as a weapon against the civilian population.

Not only is the Canadian refugee process incredibly ungenerous, it is,
at least partially, complicit in the war crimes of the Sri Lankan
government. The Canadian government gave CAD $3million in untied aid
to Sri Lanka during the bombings on Vanni that left untold dead. This
complicity gives even more reason why the government must assume some responsibility for the 76 refugees. The same can be said of Canada's role in displacement in Afghanistan, Haiti, Mexico, Columbia, Palestine and almost every other country in our globalized world where Canadian mining companies control 60% of the global market and the Canadian military actively takes part in occupations.

Instead of describing refugees as being part of the immigrant
community, and Canada, many are reinforcing racist stereotypes
dividing communities. The Immigration Minister is proposing a closing
off of borders. A new refugee system is under discussion that would
severely limit the capacity of people to claim status in Canada.
Though details are unclear, the cutting of refugee quotas by 60%,
indicate that changes will be even more exclusionary and non
democratic. Jason Kenney has gone on record saying that the system
will be re-vamped by Christmas, most likely through the establishment
of stratified acceptance process for people applying from countries
that Canada has trade relations with.

People displaced by Canada and its interests are specially part of
Canada's communal responsibility. We cannot let these refugees be used
as scapegoats by Kenney. The recent changes in the Immigration system
have emerged without public consultation and must be challenged. This
is not only a Tamil issue or a refugee issues. It's an issue of injustice. Lets all join together to fight it.

Release the 76 detainees! Status for All!

Endorsed by: Canadian Tamil Congress

In Toronto, take to the streets on December 2, 2009 at 11am. Meet at
the corner of King and University. Email nooneisillegal@riseup.net to
hear about further organizing around this.


  1. according to the government including a 'reputable terrorism expert' these people are actually Tamil Tiger agents, procuring funding/organization for their cells here in Canada not simply refugees. The government alleges that these people are part of a co-ordinated effort to reorganize the Tamil Tigers, who are an internationally recognized terrorist organization. Don't mean to be confrontational or anything, just stating what has been said in the public sphere.

  2. what has been said in the public sphere about the Tamil Tigers is devoid of any narrative that treats these people like human beings trying to flee a war torn country. The Rheoric espoused in the media filled with a nationalist discourses that aims at 'protecting' Canada from 'illigal aliens.' this ideology seems a little protectionist, irrational, colonial and racist to me! ...not to be confrontational or anything.

  3. you haven't actually addressed my point. I agree with you that Canada should welcome and protect those actually fleeing political persecution not those who commit armed insurrection and certainly not those who kill innocents en masse as the Tigers have done.

    We must not become a haven for such criminals, but a beacon of democracy and freedom and a haven for those who choose to oppose oppressive governments in civilized manner without the utilization of violence, not a collection of petty thugs who have hijacked notions of self determination in order to prop themselves and their cronies into positions of power.